Background
Through the Memorandum of Appeal dated 16th January, 2025, the Appellant appeals against the whole of the judgment of Honourable Christine Ogweno delivered on 5th December, 2024 on grounds inter alia that: -
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
Through the Memorandum of Appeal dated 16th January, 2025, the Appellant appeals against the whole of the judgment of Honourable Christine Ogweno delivered on 5th December, 2024 on grounds inter alia that: -
Paragraph 1 →In conclusion this court disagrees with the trial court decision that the Appellant did not prove that he was unfairly terminated by the Respondent and finds that the Appellant’s termination was both substantively and procedurally illegal, unfair and unjustified.
Paragraph 22 →This court finds that the Respondent was bound to issue a show cause letter, invite the Appellant for hearing over those charges and waiting for the criminal court to finalize instead of undertaking internal disciplinary proceedings, the Respondent acted in breach of the law. In any case after the criminal case was concluded where the Respondent was the complainant nothing barred it from undertaking disciplinary proceedings hence this…
Paragraph 20 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT
AT NAIROBI
APPEALS DIVISION
APPEAL NO. E010 OF 2025
THOMAS KITUNGU KILONZO…………..……..…………APPELLANT
-VERSUS-
BERMAC TYRES LMITED…………….……………...………RESPONDENT
(Being an appeal arising from the Judgment of Honourable Christine Ogweno, SRM delivered at Milimani Chief Magistrates Court in MCELRC No. E400 of 2020 on 5th December, 2024)
JUDGMENT
(Before Hon. Justice Abuodha Jorum Nelson)
1. Through the Memorandum of Appeal dated 16th January, 2025, the Appellant appeals against the whole of the judgment of Honourable Christine Ogweno delivered on 5th December, 2024 on grounds inter alia that: -
i. The Subordinate Court misdirected herself on the matters before her and the relevant law on the matter in failing to consider that the Appellant had proved his claim to the required threshold, that the Respondent’s indefinite interdiction without pay, notice of the charges against him and or the reasons for interdiction constituted unfair labour practices amounting to an unlawful, unfair and unprocedural termination thereby making a wrong and erroneous decision.
ii. The Subordinate Court in failing to appreciate and consider the Appellants’ pleadings, evidence, testimony in Court and submissions and subsequently giving more weight to the Respondent’s Pleadings and testimony, failed to appreciate that the Respondent’s conduct amounted to constructive dismissal of the Claimant from employment thereby arriving at a wrong and erroneous decision.
iii. The Subordinate Court misdirected herself on the evidence and the law on the matters before her consequently making a wrong and erroneous decision in law and fact, particularly in failing to appreciate that the Respondent’s failure to recall the Appellant back to work and reinstating him, failure to pay his earnings lost during the pendency of the criminal proceedings instituted against him, failure to issue the requisite notices or pay in lieu amounted to the unlawful constructive termination of the Appellant’s employment.
iv. The Subordinate Court misdirected herself on the matters before her and consequently failed to award compensation for the unfair interdiction and constructive dismissal of the Claimant on the basis that the Appellant failed to prove unfair termination whilst it was uncontroverted that the Claimant was never called back from the said extended unlawful interdiction period.
v. The Subordinate Court misdirected herself or acted on matters which she should not have acted upon or failed to take into consideration matters which she should have taken into consideration particularly on the issue that the Appellant was to present herself for reinstatement when it was uncontroverted that it was in fact the Respondent who had unequivocally sent her away on the unfair indefinite interdiction without any notice, information on the charges against him and when he should come back to work.
2. The Appellant therefore prayed that the Appeal be allowed with costs of this appeal and that of subordinate court and the judgment delivered on 5th December, 2024 be set aside and the Appellant’s claim be allowed.
3. The Appeal was disposed of by written submissions.
APPELLANT’S SUBMISSIONS
4. The Appellant’s Advocates Litoro & Omwebu Advocates filed written submissions dated 16th March, 2026 and submitted among others that:-
i. On the issue of whether the subordinate court erred in failing to find that the Appellant had proved unfair, wrongful and unlawful termination against the Respondent and thus entitled to the reliefs under section 49 of the Employment Act sought in the claim counsel submitted that Appellant met the established threshold governing appellate intervention thereby warranting this court’s interference with the judgment of the trial court while relying on among others the case of Selle & Another v Associated Motor Boat Co. Ltd (1968) EA 123.
ii. Counsel submitted that sections 41, 43 and 45(2) of the Employment Act sets out the framework governing unfair termination. Counsel relied on Section 47(5) of the Employment Act on the respective burden of proof between the employee and employer where the employee needs to prove unfair termination occurred and the employer justify the grounds of termination. Reliance was placed on among another the case of Josephine M. Ndungu & Others v Plan International Inc (2019) KEELRC 663 (KLR) on the respective burden of proof. Further it was submitted that the employee had the initial burden and once the employee shows a prima facie case, the burden shifted to the employer to justify termination.
iii. Counsel submitted that the Appellant had met the threshold for appellate intervention as the subordinate court misdirected itself in law and misapprehended the facts in failing to properly consider that the Appellant was indefinitely suspended, arrested and later unconditionally acquitted of all charges yet he was neither reinstated to work nor paid his accrued dues.
iv. It was submitted that the trial court misdirected itself by stating that the Appellant was employed on fixed term contract yet there was no such plea in the claim. That the trial court judgment faulting the Appellant for not notifying the Respondent that he had been discharged in the criminal case which the Respondent was the victim and complainant was consideration of irrelevant matters and misdirection on matters before him without any basis.
v. It was also the submission of the Appellant that the burden to initiate the disciplinary process or recall the Appellant to work was with the Respondent contrary to the finding of the trial court and the outcome of the criminal proceedings vindicated the Appellant. The Appellant relied on Kenya Petroleum Workers Union v Kenya Pipeline Company Limited (2014) eKLR based on which it was submitted that internal disciplinary process should be stayed pending the outcome of a criminal justice agency like in this case where the employer concluded the criminal cases and the criminal court found them not guilty the Respondent was supposed to revisit its administrative actions towards the Appellant.
vi. It was submitted that that the trial court failed to take in to consideration that the discharge and acquittal of the Appellant from criminal charges which the Respondent was the main complainant and victim for charges of stealing by servant exonerated the Appellant from the charges hence the Appellant was entitled to reinstatement.
vii. It was further submitted for the Appellant that failure by the Respondent to reinstate the Appellant without loss of earnings amounted to constructive dismissal and the Appellant proved unfair termination under Section 49 of the Employment Act. That the court should be persuaded by the decision of Kenya Petroleum Workers Union v Kenya Pipeline Company Limited (2014) eKLR that the judgment was wrong in not finding unfair termination.
viii. It was submitted that the trial court further ignored evidence of the Appellant’s unlawful indefinite suspension without notice and pay and or oral termination of employment without formal notice or termination letter, failure to follow the due process during termination, loss of his personal property during arrest and failure to pay terminal dues and salary arrears and payment in lieu of notice all of which amount to unfair, wrongful and unlawful constructive termination.
ix. Counsel submitted that the Respondent failed to discharge the burden of proving that the Appellant’s termination was fair and lawful under section 47(5) of the Employment Act. That the trial court misdirected itself in holding that the Appellant had not proved unfair termination and thus entitled to reliefs sought under section 49 of the Act.
x. On the issue of whether the Respondent’s conduct amounted to unlawful constructive dismissal of the Appellant counsel relied on among others the cases of Coca Cola East and Central Africa Limited v Maria Kagai Ligaga(2015) KECA 394 (KLR) and Maryane M Kariuki & 9 Others v Jonah Kitheka & Another (2018) KEELRC 1226 on what amounts to constructive dismissal. That the Respondent’s conduct clearly meets both limbs of constructive dismissal. That the Respondent indefinitely suspended the Appellant without any notice or a disciplinary hearing, instigated criminal proceedings against him, failed to reinstate him upon his acquittal and further withheld his salary and accrued dues.
xi. It was submitted that conduct by the Respondent amounted to a material alteration and breach of the contract to the detriment of the Appellant and made it impossible for the Appellant to perform his contract hence the constructive dismissal of the Appellant.
xii. On the issue of whether the trial court erred in failing to award the Appellant reliefs sought for unfair termination and constructive dismissal the Appellant submitted that the trial court failed to award all the reliefs sought by the Appellant in his claim dated 15-6-2020. That the trial court only awarded prayer for payment of salary arrears of Kshs 50,000/= for the month of November, 2014 and certificate of service despite having entered judgment in favour of the Appellant.
xiii. Counsel submitted that the Appellant established prima five case of unfair termination and the trial court by failing to apply the statutory provisions an consider the Appellant’s uncontested evidence the court arrived at a decision that was wrong. That the failure to award relief under section 49 of the Act particularly compensation for unlawful termination, salary arrears during the indefinite interdiction when the criminal case was pending was therefore a misdirection by the court.
xiv. On the issue of whether the Appellant was entitled to the prayers sought counsel submitted that the Appellant was entitled to the same after establishing his indefinite suspension without pay, without notice and without disciplinary hearing which amounted to unlawful constructive dismissal. That he was never recalled to duty after his acquittal hence entitled to his reliefs under section 49 of the Employment Act.
xv. It was submitted that the contract was not in writing and the Respondent did not issue any payslip to the Appellant who claimed 12 months’ salary as compensation for unfair termination at a monthly salary of Kshs 50,000/=. That he was entitled to the same at the maximum compensation for unfair termination while relying on the case of G4S Kenya Limited v Khawanga Employment and Labour Relations Appeal E046 of 2022) (2024) KEELRC 13202(KLR).
RESPONDENT’S SUBMISSIONS
5. The Respondent’s Advocates Musyoki Benson & Associates Advocates filed written submissions dated 23rd March, 2026 and submitted among others that:-
i. On the issue of whether this honourable court can interfere with the findings of the trial court counsel relied on the case of Achar v County Assembly of Kisumu. & another (Civil Appeal 56 of 2020) [2025] KECA 1781 (KLR) (24 October 2025) when it placed reliance in Selle v Associated Motor Boat Co. Ltd (1968) EA 123, on the role of this court as the first appellate court.
ii. On the issue of whether the Appellant proved termination or constructive dismissal counsel relied on Section 47(5) of the Employment Act which clearly delineates the burden of proof in such claims. It places the initial burden squarely upon the employee to demonstrate that termination has occurred. It is only after this burden has been discharged does the evidentiary burden shift to the employer to justify the termination. Reliance was placed on the Court of Appeal in Nairobi Bottlers Limited v Imbuga (Civil Appeal E661 of 2022) [2024] KECA 434 (KLR) (26 April 2024) (Judgment) on this assertion that it is the duty of the employee to prove termination was unfair.
iii. It was the submission of the Respondent in this regard that the trial court correctly found that the Appellant failed to prove that his employment was terminated at all which finding is fully supported by the evidentiary record. That the Appellant did not produce any evidence of dismissal, whether in the form of a termination letter, communication, or conduct unequivocally demonstrating severance of the employment relationship. More critically, the Appellant did not demonstrate that he took any steps to resume his duties or to assert his employment rights following the conclusion of the criminal proceedings.
iv. That the record is devoid of any evidence that he reported back to work, wrote to the Respondent seeking reinstatement, or otherwise engaged the Respondent on his employment status. On the contrary, the Respondent’s evidence, which remained largely uncontroverted, was that the Appellant did not return to work after the investigations and made no effort to regularize his position. In these circumstances, the learned trial magistrate was perfectly entitled to conclude that termination had not been proved.
v. Counsel submitted that the Appellant has attempted to recast these facts as constituting constructive dismissal. However, this argument is equally untenable. The doctrine of constructive dismissal is well settled, most notably in the Court of Appeal decision in Coca Cola East & Central Africa Ltd v Maria Kagai Ligaga [2015] eKLR. The Court laid down a stringent test requiring proof of a fundamental breach by the employer, intolerable working conditions, and a causal link leading to the employee’s resignation. In the present case, none of these elements were established.
vi. Counsel for the Respondent submitted that the Appellant did not resign from employment, nor did he demonstrate that the Respondent’s conduct rendered the working environment intolerable. There was no evidence of any repudiatory breach going to the root of the contract. The claim of constructive dismissal therefore fails both in fact and in law.
vii. It was submitted that the Appellant’s reliance on his acquittal in the criminal proceedings is equally misplaced. It is settled law that criminal proceedings and employment relationships operate in distinct spheres. An acquittal in a criminal case does not automatically translate into reinstatement or establish wrongful termination. This principle was clearly articulated by the Court of Appeal in Judicial Service Commission v Gladys Boss Shollei [2014] eKLR, where the Court emphasized that employment disputes must be assessed independently of criminal outcomes. That the Appellant to prove unfair termination and the trial court was justified in finding as such.
viii. On the issue of whether the Appellant was entitled to the remedies under section 49 it was submitted that the remedies provided under Section 49 of the Employment Act, including compensation for unfair termination, are predicated upon a finding that termination was both established and unfair. In the absence of such a finding, the remedies cannot arise. Reliance was placed on the case of Kenfreight (EA) Limited v Benson K. Nguti [2016] eKLR, where the Court held that compensation is only awardable where unfair termination has been proved.
ix. It was submitted that the trial court awarded the only prayer proved of salary arrears for November 2014 as well a certificate of service hence the court exercised its discretion judiciously.
DETERMINATION
6. The court has considered the grounds of appeal, the record of appeal and submissions filed by the both parties herein and notes that in this case, the Judgment of the trial court was that the Appellant partially proved his claim and dismissed the rest of the prayers while allowing the Appellant’s claim for salary arrears for November 2014 at Kshs 50,000/= The Appellant as Claimant in the lower court was aggrieved by the judgment and now appeals on the whole of the Judgment raising 6 grounds in his memorandum of appeal which this court will condense in to two issues namely:-
a. Whether the trial court erred by finding that unfair termination was not proved.
b. WHEHWWwWhetherWhetherWhe Whether the trial court erred by not allowing the reliefs sought by the Appellant.
Whether the trial court erred by finding that unfair termination was not proved
7. It is not in dispute that the Respondent employed the Appellant at a remuneration of Ksh. 50,000/= per month in September 2013 although there was no evidence of a written contract which went against the provisions of section 8, 9 and 10 of the Employment Act which requires the employer to reduce down the employment contract in to writing. Section 10(7) of the Act places the burden of proving or disproving a term of employment contract on employer where they do not produce a written contract. Courts have also held that they would believe the employees word if the engagement is oral in nature.
8. The Appellant’s case was that he was suspended and then dismissed without notice. It was his case that there was no letter of termination issued upon him. The case of the Respondent on the other hand was that the Appellant was a consultant and not accountant and never returned to work after investigations against him on allegations of stealing by servant.
9. The Appellant was employed on 1st September 2013 and worked up to 6th December 2014. The terms of employment are not disputed. The Appellant’s case was that he was suspended without a notice or disciplinary action. Whereas the Appellant’s burden was to prove unfair termination, the Respondent bore the burden to justify the grounds for termination. This the requirement under section 47(5) of the Employment Act which provides the respective burden of proof.
10. In this case, it was said that there was no termination at all. However, the relationship between the parties was not of the nature to bespeak a smooth working relation. It was the common position of the parties that the Appellant had been implicated in a stealing. An accusation which in his view felt was fabricated against him. This followed investigations and prosecution even though he was later acquitted of the charges.
11. Whether the acquittal was proper is not the concern of this court. Courts have settled this issue that criminal proceedings do not bar an employer from undertaking internal disciplinary proceedings on the same charges. The employer can still dismiss an employee on the same charges even if the same employee was acquitted in the criminal court. The two carry different standards of proof where the criminal court it is proof beyond reasonable doubt while in internal disciplinary proceedings it is on balance of probabilities.
12. That the procedural and substantive fairness following alleged misconduct is what this court is concerned with. The court in Walter Ogal Anuro -vs- Teachers Service Commission (2013) eKLR held that for termination to pass the fairness test, it must be shown that there was not only substantive justification for termination but also procedural fairness.
13. The Court of Appeal further in the case of Kenya Revenue Authority v Menginya Salim Murgani [2010] eKLR observed thus;
“there is ample authority that decision making bodies other than courts and bodies whose procedure are laid down by statute are masters of their own procedures. Provided they achieve the degree of fairness appropriate to their task. It is for them to decide how they will proceed.”
14. The Appellant had worked for slightly more than one year. He was clearly not on probation. The Respondent was tasked with keeping employment related records. From such records, it would be discerned whether due process was followed. The Appellant as the custodian of employment records under section 74 of the Employment Act had a duty to illustrate the nature of work by the Appellant and indeed that the Appellant stopped working once he was implicated in the alleged theft.
15. This court notes that the Appellant was accused of stealing. Substantive justice required proper internal procedure which would entail suspending him with half pay to pave way for investigations and subsequently hearing him on the allegations. This procedure was necessary regardless of the action by the state agencies over the crime allegations. The Respondent was bound to prove the reason for termination as required under section 43 of the Employment Act which if not proved amounted to unfair termination under section 45 of the Act.
16. In assessing the legality of suspension, the Court of Appeal in Mutwol v Moi University (Civil Appeal 118 of 2019) [2022] KECA 537 (KLR) (28 April 2022) adopted the position in the Canadian case of Cabiakman v. Industrial Alliance Life Insurance Co., 2004 SCC 55, [2004] 3 S.C.R. 195, in which the Supreme Court laid down several factors that can guide the courts in determining whether an employer was justified in deciding to temporarily suspend an employee thus:
“This residual power to suspend for administrative reasons because of acts of which the employee has been accused is an integral part of any contract of employment, but it is limited and must be exercised in accordance with the following requirements: (1) the action taken must be necessary to protect legitimate business interests; (2) the employer must be guided by good faith and the duty to act fairly in deciding to impose an administrative suspension; (3) the temporary interruption of the employee’s performance of the work must be imposed for a relatively short period that is or can be fixed, or else it would be little different from a resiliation or dismissal pure and simple; and (4) the suspension must, other than in exceptional circumstances that do not apply here, be with pay”
17. From the above case, even though suspension of an employee is allowed, there are those factors which must be met more so the same being short period of suspension and with pay. In this case the suspension was until the criminal case was finalized from 2014 to 2018 which was a long period and without pay which was not only unreasonable but unlawful. The termination of a contract of employment should be backed with substantive justification. In this case, in the absence of contrary information, the Appellant was an employee of the Respondent in the manner pleaded in the claim. The Court in Galgalo Jarso Jillo v Agricultural Finance Corporation [2021] eKLR held as follows:
In terms of section 43 of the Employment Act, an employer will be deemed to have a substantive justification for terminating a contract of service if he/she genuinely believed that the matters that informed the decision to terminate existed at the time the decision was taken. In other words, it is not a requirement of the law that the substantive ground informing the decision to terminate must in fact be in existence. All that is required is for the employer to have a reasonable basis for genuinely believing that the ground exists even if it later turns out that it, in fact, did not. In my view, what the law is concerned with here is whether the circumstances surrounding the decision to terminate would justify a reasonable man on the street, standing in the same position as the employer, to reach a similar decision as him/her regarding the termination.’
18. In this case the Respondent never issued the Appellant with termination notice but he was suspended indefinitely while awaiting the outcome of the criminal case but still after the same was concluded, it did not communicate the way forward. That is to say whether to start its disciplinary process on the self-same charges constituting the criminal case or reinstate the appellant. The court is equally not satisfied that suspension alone could entitle the Respondent to stop the whole of the Appellant’s salary with immediate effect. In the above case of Galgalo Jarso Jillo v Agricultural Finance Corporation (supra) the Court stated as follows:
Therefore, it does appear to me that to unilaterally withhold the entire pay of an employee merely because he is on suspension would be in breach of the contract of service unless sanctioned by law. What appears to be a reasonable middle ground to ensure the contract remains alive during the disciplinary process is the practice of withholding a portion of the pay even as the other is released. I have made these comments in my decision because part of the claims by the Claimant relate to the period during which he was on suspension.
19. This therefore meant that the withholding of the Appellant’s salary while on indefinite suspension amounted to constructive dismissal as well as unfair termination. On the procedural fairness as provided for under Section 41 of the Employment Act this court notes that the same was never adhered to as the Respondent as seen above never illustrated commencing a disciplinary process or giving the Appellant any hearing hence the Respondent violated the clear provisions of section 41 of the Act since the criminal proceedings are different from internal disciplinary proceedings.
20. This court finds that the Respondent was bound to issue a show cause letter, invite the Appellant for hearing over those charges and waiting for the criminal court to finalize instead of undertaking internal disciplinary proceedings, the Respondent acted in breach of the law. In any case after the criminal case was concluded where the Respondent was the complainant nothing barred it from undertaking disciplinary proceedings hence this amounted to unfair termination.
21. The court is guided by the holding in the case of Kenya Union of Commercial Food and Allied Workers v Meru North Farmers Sacco Limited [2014] eKLR that: -
Section 41 of the Employment Act is couched in mandatory terms. Where an employer fails to follow these mandatory provisions, whatever outcome of the process is bound to be unfair as the affected employee has not been accorded a hearing in the presence of their union representative.
22. In conclusion this court disagrees with the trial court decision that the Appellant did not prove that he was unfairly terminated by the Respondent and finds that the Appellant’s termination was both substantively and procedurally illegal, unfair and unjustified.
Whether the trial court erred by not allowing the reliefs sought by the Appellant.
23. The trial court having erred in its finding that there was no unfair termination was wrong in failing to award reliefs to the Appellant. The trial court only awarded November 2014 salary at Kshs 50,000/=. This court finds that the Appellant was unfairly terminated hence entitled to the compensation under Section 49(1) of the Employment Act. The award of compensation is discretionary but the court should be guided by considerations set out under Section 49(4) of the Employment Act in awarding the damages herein.
24. This court takes notes the fact that the Respondent had served the Appellant for 1 year hence an award of two months’ salary as compensation would be adequate in the circumstances. The award of one-month in lieu of notice was also justified after finding the Appellant was unfairly terminated without notice as provided for under section 35 of the Employment Act. The same is awarded at Ksh. 50,000/=.
25. On the claim for salary arrears for November 2014, the court notes the trial court awarded this at Ksh. 50,000/= which is upheld. On the accrued salary while on suspension the law allows employees to be paid half salary while on suspension and this court allow the same from December, 2014 to July, 2018 when the Criminal case was determined as nothing barred the Respondent from initiating disciplinary proceedings while the criminal case was ongoing. There was no basis of waiting for the conclusion of the criminal case to take the next step.
26. In the upshot, the Appeal is merited and is hereby allowed as follows:
a) Judgment of the lower court is set aside and substituted with an order awarding the Appellant as follows:
I. One month’s salary in lieu of notice of Ksh. 50,000/=.
II. Two months’ salary as compensation for unfair termination of employment of Ksh. 100,000/=
III. Half salary from December 2014 to July 2018 which 44 months x 25,000= Kshs 1,100,000/=
Total: 1,250,000/- The award shall be subject to statutory deduction but shall attract interest at court rates from the date of this judgment until payment in full.
IV. Certificate of service
b) For the avoidance of doubt, the award on salary arrears for November 2014 is not disturbed.
c) The Appellant shall have costs in the lower court and in this Appeal.
27. It is so ordered.
Dated at Nairobi this 5TH day of November 2026
Delivered virtually this 5th day of November 2026
Abuodha Nelson Jorum
Presiding Judge-Appeals Division